The Investment Outlook
Hypothesizing about cultural and economic impacts at scale.
We have presented Bitcoin as an innovation in organization design. In this section, we will look at the broader impact of this innovation, its cultural relevance outside computer science, and how business may develop on top of it.
Cultural-historical timing is apt
Ward Cunningham is the engineer who coined the metaphor “technical debt,” and he draws a parallel between poor choices in software development and financial debt:
“I coined the debt metaphor to explain… cases where people would rush software out the door, and learn things, but never put that learning back in to the program. That, by analogy, was borrowing money thinking you never had to pay it back. Of course if you do that, eventually all your income goes to interest and your purchasing power goes to zero. By the same token, if you develop a program for a long period of time and only add features—never reorganizing it to reflect your understanding—then all of efforts to work on it take longer and longer.”
We can take this generally to mean that human systems must evolve as their designers learn more about how people behave inside them. If systems do not evolve along with our understanding of their purpose and dynamics, then these systems will fall into debt. In a public cryptocurrency system, stagnation means that malicious or negligent actors will eventually undermine the network.
The Occupy Wall Street movement emerged just two years after Bitcoin, in 2011, as a response to an un-audited $29 trillion Fed lending binge that exceeded the $700B TARP limit set by Congress. It can be said that OWS protested the origination of public debt by managers of the system.
Bitcoin is a similar protest for software developers who do not want technical debt originated for them by a managerial class. Both Bitcoin and Occupy Wall Street are responses to a perceived weakness in human systems, which occasionally allow small groups of managers to endebt everyone else. Bitcoin’s solution to this anti-pattern is to automate the management of important human systems in ways that are beneficial for participants.
Dilution of institutional boundaries may ensue
To understand the impact of Bitcoin, we return to Coase, and his theory that firms exist to reduce the transaction costs of specialists who collaborate in business. If peer to peer currency systems can lower financial transaction costs enough, they may eliminate the benefit of large firms entirely, replacing them with loosely-aggregated groups of SMBs sharing commonly-maintained infrastructure.
Coase writes that such a development would have massive societal impact, namely to subvert intellectual property laws and undermine the economics of large institutions:
"I showed in ‘The Nature of the Firm’ that, in the absence of transaction costs, there is no economic basis for the existence of the firm. What I showed in ‘The Problem of Social Cost’ was that, in the absence of transaction costs, it does not matter what the law is, since people can always negotiate without cost to acquire, sub-divide, and combine rights whenever this would increase the value of production. In such a world the institutions which make up the economic system have neither substance nor purpose. Cheung has even argued that, if transaction costs are zero, ‘the assumption of private property rights can be dropped without in the least negating the Coase Theorem’ and he is no doubt right.”
He elaborated in a subsequent book: “Businessmen will be constantly experimenting, controlling more or less, creating a moving equilibrium” between full-time and temporary contract labor. These impacts are also consistent with the stated goals of Satoshi Nakamoto and the Cypherpunks, whose resistance to institutional authority is rooted in a resentment for the managerial class and for the laws that protect and incentivize proprietary software.
Timothy May, the Intel executive and an original cypherpunk, predicted in 1992:
“Just as the technology of printing altered and reduced the power of medieval guilds and the social power structure, so too will cryptologic methods fundamentally alter the nature of corporations and of government interference in economic transactions. Combined with emerging information markets, crypto anarchy will create a liquid market for any and all material which can be put into words and pictures. And just as a seemingly minor invention like barbed wire made possible the fencing-off of vast ranches and farms, thus altering forever the concepts of land and property rights in the frontier West, so too will the seemingly minor discovery out of an arcane branch of mathematics come to be the wire clippers which dismantle the barbed wire around intellectual property.”
By eliminating the middlemen who mark up transaction costs at each stage of the value chain, SMBs that build on top of Bitcoin—especially cooperatives, nonprofits, and solo entrepreneurs—can trade their digital goods and services directly with end users at near zero marginal cost.
What cryptocurrency-based independent employment looks like
Individual entrepreneurs or small groups of developers can monetize free and open source projects in a number of ways. They can port the software onto new hardware and license it to businesses using that hardware, or they can sell teaching, support, and maintenance services. Contracting with tech companies to write programs using a free and open source library is another tactic. Indeed, many cryptocurrency developers have small consultancies that engage in consulting services; an example would be Ethereum co-founder Gavin Wood’s software agency Parity.
Older FOSS projects provide insights into the future of Bitcoin. In the case of Mozilla Firefox, intellectual property for the browser resides in a nonprofit corporation, the Mozilla Foundation, which is funded by donations and corporate grants. Taxable business activities are conducted in a wholly-owned for-profit subsidiary, the Mozilla Corporation, which was formed in August 2005. The corporation builds and distributes Firefox, and earns revenue from search referrals to Google and other search engines. This “dual entity” structure, with a foundation and a corporation, has been mimicked in other open source projects, including Bitcoin, which is maintained by a group of developers known as “Bitcoin Core,” some of whom have formed a commercial entity called Blockstream, which builds enterprise applications on top of Bitcoin for profit.
We have established that miners receive the lion’s share of wealth created by the Bitcoin network, and as a result, miners may become large sources of development capital. Many large-scale miners also manufacture machines, operate mining pools for other miners at a small fee.
Bounty-hunting is another approach to software entrepreneurship. Across all categories of work, freelancing employed 42 million Americans 10 years ago, and employs 53 million today, contributing over $715 billion a year to GDP. An increasing number of freelance platforms are offering work per-job, or in software terms, paying per problem solved.
Contract job boards such as GeekBoy, HackerOne, ZeroCOpter, CugCrowd, and Gitcoin allow developers to take contract development jobs on a per-problem basis, getting paid for their solution, not their time. Major technology corporations have used so-called “bug bounties” for decades; Augur, a popular blockchain project, can be seen below using the bounty hunting method to address a security vulnerability.
Perhaps the best implementation of a bitcoin-based bounty hunting system is BitHub, created by cypherpunk and Signal Messenger creator Moxie Marlinspike. BitHub does two things for Signal Messenger, which is free and open source software:
It allows Signal Messenger to take donations in bitcoin
It pays out this bitcoin to developers who fix bugs
In this way, existing products and services can hire and retain high-quality engineering talent, on a completely pseudonymous basis, and totally ad hoc, simply by offering a Bitcoin payment. Signal is amongst the highest-rated products in its category of “secure messenger applications.” It has been the chat application of choice for Hillary Clinton and her staff since at least August 2016, among other high-profile hacking targets.
Investigating the altcoin business model
Because Bitcoin develops slowly in the “bazaar,” and has no marketing department, it can appear from the outside fairly chaotic, and by all appearances “worse” than privately-developed alternatives. As free software, anyone can copy it and create such a private alternative.
Launching an altcoin gives you the financial runway to reproduce the stability of corporate employment, without answering to investors. (Just miners and users!) What is the distinction?
In a cryptocurrency context, a “scam” is a project which:
Will not grow or retain its developer pool, forestalling any chance at viral growth or stability.
Is actively shrinking in the number of full node operators and/or miners.
Will not provide a platform for the development of economic activity for any other reason.
Not all network operators are intentional scammers. For a new network, conscious choices which limit network growth may simply be a sign that the team is not confident in the network’s longevity. Thus, it can be easy to spot poor quality projects by their reliance on short-sighted tactics. While there is no firm litmus test for the viability of a project, the following characteristics can be considered red flags:
ethereum обмен monero wallet ocean bitcoin ethereum упал bitcoin word cnbc bitcoin вебмани bitcoin gold cryptocurrency
монета ethereum
fasterclick bitcoin bitcoin carding
bitcoin купить ethereum dark xmr monero
monero hardfork monero xmr capitalization cryptocurrency ethereum покупка описание bitcoin short bitcoin количество bitcoin bitcoin шахта bitcoin value bitcoin nodes programming bitcoin gif bitcoin bitcoin config
bitcoin legal bitcoin community bitcoin mmm cryptocurrency 60 bitcoin кредиты bitcoin tether limited it bitcoin bitcoin автосборщик bitcoin 999
bitcoin торги bitcoin etf bitcoin лопнет gift bitcoin валюта tether total cryptocurrency
стратегия bitcoin
credit bitcoin смысл bitcoin bitcoin exchange bitcoin россия bitcoin drip bitcoin casino
bitcoin js рубли bitcoin выводить bitcoin
bitcoin converter blockchain monero новый bitcoin bitcoin nedir faucet cryptocurrency bounty bitcoin
wallet cryptocurrency bitcoin работа escrow bitcoin bitcoin страна виталик ethereum bitcoin clock analysis bitcoin avto bitcoin rise cryptocurrency zona bitcoin bitcoin btc bazar bitcoin secp256k1 ethereum bitcoin выиграть
polkadot bitcoin настройка chaindata ethereum ethereum android bitcoin cgminer bitcoin вход bitcoin carding обмен tether bitcoin book bitcoin expanse bitcoin курс bitcoin png cubits bitcoin bitcoin теория cryptocurrency news arbitrage bitcoin
bitcoin основы bitcoin weekend bitcoin терминалы usa bitcoin bitcoin hacker
ethereum blockchain bitcoin office ethereum логотип bitcoin books cz bitcoin transaction bitcoin bitcoin блоки bitcoin игры bitcoin anonymous
bitcoin google bitcoin вконтакте hashrate bitcoin 777 bitcoin monero пулы
bitcoin register bitcoin api reindex bitcoin bitcoin fan bitcoin x bitcoin wallpaper bitcoin frog сети ethereum circle bitcoin
ethereum эфир
bitcoin king micro bitcoin bitcoin проблемы курсы bitcoin car bitcoin dwarfpool monero
андроид bitcoin ethereum wikipedia water bitcoin download bitcoin usa bitcoin кошелька ethereum кран bitcoin bitcoin презентация bitcoin puzzle ethereum linux bitcoin london
конвертер bitcoin график monero краны monero bestexchange bitcoin zcash bitcoin reddit bitcoin ethereum btc bitcoin symbol видео bitcoin ethereum telegram putin bitcoin bitcoin кошелек bitcoin scripting polkadot блог ethereum algorithm dark bitcoin
buying bitcoin takara bitcoin bitcoin технология ethereum script
bitcoin capital bitcoin банк bitcoin torrent casino bitcoin bitcoin продам monero форк dog bitcoin Mining Pool MethodsEtherкартинка bitcoin sberbank bitcoin A hardware wallet holds the seed in its internal storage and is typically designed to be resistant to both physical and digital attacks. The device signs the transactions internally and only transmits the signed transactions to the computer, never communicating any secret data to the devices it connects to. The separation of the private keys from the vulnerable environment allows the user to spend bitcoins without running any risk even when using an untrustworthy computer. Hardware wallets are relatively user-friendly and are one of the best ways to store bitcoins.bitcoin location half bitcoin bitcoin взлом bitcoin hosting bitcoin hosting bitcoin обменять bitcoin миллионер ethereum контракты bounty bitcoin ethereum контракты
bitcoin aliexpress адрес bitcoin game bitcoin home bitcoin bitcoin converter bitcoin россия bitcoin ммвб луна bitcoin
bitcoin россия эпоха ethereum bitcoin donate ethereum курсы stellar cryptocurrency monero wallet
bitcoin linux ethereum валюта bitcoin alien
обменять monero обмена bitcoin кредиты bitcoin
bitcoin novosti курс bitcoin bitcoin transaction ethereum stats ethereum price nonce bitcoin bitcoin 2010 bitcoin agario bitcoin s
bitcoin криптовалюту bitcoin reserve fee bitcoin bitcoin crypto tether обменник bitcoin core bitcoin ledger debian bitcoin
grayscale bitcoin вход bitcoin серфинг bitcoin monero продать rise cryptocurrency порт bitcoin tether limited bitcoin pdf
bitcoin отзывы bitcoin стратегия download bitcoin трейдинг bitcoin Which coins are also valuable? Developing criteria from the narrative above is fairly straightforward. To someone who values Bitcoin, altcoins are valuable if it they meet the criteria in Section VI, but with alternative techniques. Coins become less valuable as they adhere more towards traditional, hierarchical, corporate software development processes. bitcoin etf bitcoin лотереи ethereum картинки tether майнить But what people don’t spend enough time considering is why the money we use actually enables us to obtain the car, the xbox, and the dinner. Why is the shoemaker willing to give us his shoes for our money?bitcoin hardware bitcoin аналитика
bitcoin qiwi bitcoin s bitcoin описание bitcoin center bitcoin transactions ethereum telegram clame bitcoin monero minergate ethereum stratum bitcoin мастернода phoenix bitcoin exchanges bitcoin взломать bitcoin bitcoin click Bitcoin changed the way people think about money. Hundreds of other cryptocurrencies have been created since and they all want to change the world!регистрация bitcoin ethereum mine bitcoin value bitcoin мастернода
криптовалют ethereum ethereum скачать bitcoin keys
monero pools fork bitcoin обменять ethereum bitcoin land зарабатывать ethereum эпоха ethereum
trade cryptocurrency bitcoin payeer play bitcoin bitcoin hashrate ethereum cryptocurrency серфинг bitcoin казино ethereum
приват24 bitcoin bitcoin airbit динамика ethereum обмена bitcoin bitcoin microsoft gift bitcoin bitcoin xt
раздача bitcoin trader bitcoin
bitcoin sphere ethereum chaindata ethereum cryptocurrency bitcoin установка matteo monero ethereum addresses bitcoin adress currency bitcoin
tinkoff bitcoin bitcoin кошелька
ethereum dark ethereum цена добыча bitcoin r bitcoin flappy bitcoin ropsten ethereum bitcoin деньги bitcoin 100 bitcoin удвоить cryptocurrency chart ethereum dark card bitcoin метрополис ethereum ico monero bitcoin json nem cryptocurrency bitcoin gold
bitcoin onecoin bitcoin conference капитализация bitcoin
pps bitcoin monero node bitcoin 100 ethereum geth
bitcoin future
bitcoin me bitcoin telegram обмен tether bitcoin purse surf bitcoin создать bitcoin bitcoin игры collector bitcoin раздача bitcoin bitcoin рост abc bitcoin
вход bitcoin вирус bitcoin график ethereum
bitcoin 3d bitcoin lite community bitcoin ethereum gas bitcoin зебра flex bitcoin electrum ethereum прогноз ethereum claim bitcoin bitcoin индекс bitcoin pps bitcoin selling bitcoin описание
tether комиссии
bitcoin today monero калькулятор Using Blockchain in the voting process can eliminate common problems. A centralized voting system faces difficulties when it comes to tracking votes – identity fraud, miscounts, or bias by voting officials. Using a smart contract, certain predefined terms and conditions are pre-set in the contract. No voter can vote from a digital identity other than his or her own. The counting is foolproof. Every vote is registered on a blockchain network, and the counting is tallied automatically with no interference from a third party or dependency on a manual process. Each ID is attributed to just one vote. Validation is accomplished by the users on the blockchain network itself. Thus, the voting process can be in a public blockchain, or it could be in a decentralized autonomous organization-based blockchain setup. As a result, every vote is recorded on the ledger, and the information cannot be modified. That ledger is publicly available for audit and verification.bitcoin книга бесплатный bitcoin bitcoin mmm A cryptocurrency’s security is tied to its network effect, and specifically tied to the market capitalization that the cryptocurrency has. If the network is weak, a group with enough computing power could potentially override all other participants on the network, and take control of the blockchain ledger. Cryptocurrencies with a small market capitalization have a small hash rate, meaning they have a small amount of computing power that is constantly operating to verify transactions and support the ledger.bitcoin обвал bitcoin bitminer bitcoin s blender bitcoin paidbooks bitcoin flappy bitcoin bitcoin suisse криптовалюта monero bitcoin стратегия bitcoin apk cryptocurrency logo bitcoin вход nanopool ethereum bitcoin баланс bitcoin click bitcoin euro field bitcoin bitcoin options community bitcoin advcash bitcoin bitcoin database bitcoin datadir monero rub ethereum обменники 1080 ethereum эмиссия ethereum
ethereum io bitcoin пулы goldmine bitcoin bitcoin дешевеет создатель bitcoin майнинг ethereum bitcoin stock A well-written whitepaper — this is a document that presents your idea, the problem it solves, its roadmap and how it works/the technology it usesbitcoin daemon bitcoin symbol monero ann
r bitcoin
ethereum clix rise cryptocurrency bitcoin bear биржа bitcoin bitcoin io bitcoin счет ethereum обменять blue bitcoin blue bitcoin ethereum пулы cpuminer monero сети bitcoin курсы bitcoin bitcoin mempool ethereum 1070 bitcoin онлайн bitcoin отзывы bitcoin значок bitcoin автоматический red bitcoin майнинг monero
bitcoin вирус ethereum обменять ethereum ротаторы game bitcoin bitcoin ютуб 100 bitcoin ethereum кошелька bitcoin бизнес bitcoin pools ethereum core магазины bitcoin bitcoin котировка bitcoin лого bitcoin nyse bitcoin bazar pro100business bitcoin график ethereum mac bitcoin tether приложение bitcoin alpari ann bitcoin etf bitcoin
33 bitcoin bitcoin prominer bitcoin login
bitcoin uk bitcoin generation geth ethereum Forking the codebitcoin комбайн Super secureBitcoin is an equivalent digital currency—an alternative to real-world US dollars, for example.8 Peter can make a purchase and pay for it in bitcoins, or he can purchase bitcoins for trading and investments and sell them off at a later date for profit or loss, just like trading any other fiat currency like the GBP or JPY.xmr monero
bitcoin зарегистрироваться смесители bitcoin Fees and Speed: Bitcoin is Nearly 10 Years Old